Days Without End by Sebastian Barry (Man Booker Prize long list 2017)


It’s a dark thing when the world sets no value  on you or your kin, and then Death comes stalking in, in his bloody boots.

And now I come to another book with incredible writing, a turn of phrase, or an expression, that will make me alternatively pause to think or smile or both.

Thomas  McNulty tells us his story, that after fleeing Ireland he caught up with John Cole, and these two became inseparable first working in a bar dressed as young girls so the men would have dancing partners, and then signing up to join the army.

They fight the Indians on the frontier in the 1850’s, and there is a ghastly retelling of each misunderstanding and massacre the soldiers encounter.

You can’t have nothing good in war without you punishing the guilty, the sergeant says with a savage air and no one says nothing against that. John Cole whispers to me that most times that sergeant he just wrong but just now and then he’s right and he’s right this time. I guess I’m thinking this is true. We get drunk then and the sergeant is clutching his belly all evening and then everything is blotted out till you awake in the bright early morning needing a piss and then it all floods back into your brain what happened and it makes your heart yelp like a dog.

For who is the sergeant to say what is right and what is wrong? Plus, these soldiers are at a disadavantage as they are in the “awkward position of being clumsy-footed Europeans near a village of geniuses when it comes to tracking and vigilance.”

Only after awhile John Cole’s body isn’t quite right, somehow, and it is decided that they will not sign up again when the time comes round.

They take a young Sioux girl, Winona, and set off for a new life, hoping at the same time that they can form a family since her father had been killed. They are a group of misfits to be sure, but misfits who love one another all the more for their lack of belonging elsewhere.

Next thing you know, they are called into service for the Civil War, a situation which seems as bungled and bloody as fighting the Indians ever was.

Nothing too tricky about dying for your country. It’s the easiest item on the menu. God knows the truth of it. Young Seth McCarthy he come up from Missouri to be a drummer boy in the Federal army and what does he get only his head took off by a Federal Shell.

When they end their time serving in that war, they are mere shadows of their former selves, skeletal men who hunger for more than food. They answer a compatriot’s call to come to Tennessee and help with the tobacco farm he cannot manage on his own, and so Thomas, John and Winona go there while we hope that this is a place where they can at last find a normal life. Or, at least some comfort from the hardships they have endured.

This is a beautiful book, a story of much more than war and poverty and loneliness. I found it quite moving; my mother liked it so much she is presenting it to her Book Club this August as a “must read”.


13 thoughts on “Days Without End by Sebastian Barry (Man Booker Prize long list 2017)”

  1. I know this is beautifully written and deserving of all the accolades, but I’m not sure I’ll get to any more on this list, I’m drawn towards more diverse pastures, places and voices that are little heard for now. Lovely review and happy your mother is spreading the word of its merits too!


    1. I’m assuming that your heart, like mine, lies in closest proximity to those books which are in translation. I understand a calling elsewhere, but thank you for taking the time to read this post and comment.

      Liked by 1 person

  2. Mr.Barry astounded me on every page, the lyricism lept out and I pondered how war could be lyrical. Mr. Barry showed me by giving details that enlighten the reader never horrifying until in retrospect you are shocked with the depth of feeling he has exposed, and the amazing way you have accepted his premises and his characters. That they are real is never in doubt, like the language, nuance and vocabulary which establishes a narrator of particular time and place. A fascinating story. Mjh


  3. If the first paragraph is too much, this book is probably not for you. I am usually quite quesy when it comes to war, but somehow I loved it. I loved the relationships created, and the authenticity of language, and was not in the least disappointed in the ending, so for me it worked.

    Solar Bones was another fascinating novel. You might really like that one.


Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Google photo

You are commenting using your Google account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s