The Mathematician’s Shiva by Stuart Rojastaczer


The Mathematician’s Shiva by Stuart Rojstaczer is ostensibly a novel about a shiva held for mathematician Rachela Karnakovitch. But it is much more than describing the seven days one sits in honor of the loss of a loved one. No, this novel is an homage to mathematicians and scientists, Russia and America, mothers and fathers, but most of all to courage and strength.

It is told through the narrative of Sasha, Rachela’s son, interspersed with chapters from her own memoir. We catch a glimpse of what it meant to have lived through the war, suffering under Stalin’s terrible hand. Yet that which does not kill us, can only make us stronger. Or, as my mother would say to me, “Courage grows strong in a wound.”

Rachela learns mathematics as a child, an eleven year old girl who is close to starvation. Through the deprivation she endured, and the brilliant mind she possessed, she became adept at solving complex mathematical problems. Her life was unique as a Soviet defector, a Jew, and a woman who was a genius in mathematics.

She writes in her memoir, “I needed a war to make me into a mathematician. I needed deprivation to make me appreciate every little gift, every tiny increment-like a crumb of food, yes-of understanding while solving a problem. I don’t believe a spoiled child, even one encouraged to pursue the intellectual world, can ever be anything more than a second-rate mathematician. This is what war gave me, a life of the mind that would sustain me almost always.”

It took a great deal of courage to sustain herself. As a child she left Russia with her parents; as a young mother she defected to America certain that her husband and son would find a way to follow.

When she dies from lung cancer at the age of 70, the problem faced by her son is how to keep her funeral from “turning into a Russian theatrical tragedy.” A private ceremony is not possible; the great mathematical minds of Rachela’s world insist on sitting shiva with her family, for they are convinced that her solution to the famously difficult Navier-Stokes problem lies somewhere in her home.

The dialogue, the relationships, the insight into family life in general, and the minds of incredibly strong women in particular, is what makes this novel shine. It is a novel I devoured in one day, making my Labor Day vacation one long to be remembered. This is one of the most spectacular novels I have read this year, for I feel that Stuart Rojstaczer has written what it means to be an immigrant with incredible determination finding one’s way in America. He has written of American strengths and idiosyncrasies with an appraising eye. He has written of a son’s love for his mother, for his family, for his history with a tenderness that almost makes me weep. Except for the parts where I laughed with joy at the connection I found between his family and my own.

16 thoughts on “The Mathematician’s Shiva by Stuart Rojastaczer”

  1. I'd seen this one mentioned before, but hadn't paid any attention to it. After reading your post, I'm most definitely going to be getting my hands on a copy. It sounds fantastic! So glad that this book made such an impression on you – I love it when books do that 😉


  2. I was able to read it as Penguin sent me a copy. It is new to me as well, and I am so happy I had the opportunity to review it. Not all the books I've received are like that, sadly.


  3. Yes, mathematics can be a rather alarming subject to some of us (me), but don't worry. This novel only dwells on the mathematical mind and higher level problems are only mentioned, not intended for us to solve.


  4. Shore acres, I remember you expressing interest when I first tweeted that I received this book. Glad you give some credence to my reviews and are looking forward to reading it yourself. 😉



  5. I hadn't heard of this novel at all until I read your post, and it sounds as if it's a book that resonates with you on a personal level.

    Love the new header pic and blog makeover, btw! Very smart.


  6. It is one of the things that helps me get over times that are hard. Wounds can defeat us, of course, but they can also teach us how to be brave. It's so nice to hear from you, Natalie!


  7. The heroine of the novel reminds me very much of my grandmother and my mother, not because they are mathematicians, nor because they escaped Russia, but because all three are very brave. Weakness is not tolerated in Sasha's family, much as it was not in ours. It's rather opposite of many homes I see today.

    As for the new header and pic, I am notorious for changing my blog. I often switch the 'reclining woman' to another reader. I just feel the need for color once in awhile, and this is one of my favorite reader paintings.


  8. I've never heard of this novel, but it sounds like one I might enjoy. Off to add it to my list. Marvelous review, Meredith. You have quite a way with words.


  9. Les, thank you for your sweet compliment, though really I feel quite stuck in my thoughts and expressions right now; not as if I had a way with words at all. I think my creativity is going straight to my class, which is where it ought to be right now I guess. I think you will enjoy this book as much as I did. In rereading my review I made it sound so very serious, which it is, but there are lovely humorous parts, too.


Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Google photo

You are commenting using your Google account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s