Russian Winter by Daphne Kalotay

Winter 1951. Moonlight stretches the warped shadows of buildings, enormous and looming, over the square. Nina feels their presence like a weight above her as she crosses, shivering, toward the Bolshoi. Already the building is swarming with security guards. The ones at the entrance hold bayoneted rifles across their chests and, though Nina has become a recognizable face, make her show a special pass with her photograph on it, which they scrutinize coldly before allowing her in. For the rest of the night she will be made to show this pass, again and again, to enter her dressing room, the makeup room, the bathroom…..even before stepping onstage (when she will have to tuck the stiff little card somewhere under costume and pray it doesn’t slip out.)

I have long been inexplicably entranced by Russia. I have collected the little black boxes painted with a single haired brush, taken more Russian literature courses in college than English, read Anna Karenina more times than I can count.

Last night my friend and I went out for coffee, and I told her how much I loved this book. “It’s not one of those like that Pasternak guy,” she said, “who was it that wrote Crime and Punishment?”

Dr. Zhivago,” I said, “He wrote Dr. Zhivago, and this is nothing like it.”

“Oh, good,” she replied, “I had to give that up after the first four pages with all those crazy names…”

No, this novel is not filled with ‘crazy names’. But, it is filled with the way that people had to live under Stalin’s leadership. Interspersed with that time period and today is the story of Nina Revskaya, a prima ballerina, who refuses to talk about the past let alone the amber jewelry which she has offered for auction. The other characters who enter in are Grigori Solodin and Drew Brooks who help unravel the mystery behind Nina’s dreadful, and heart-wrenching, secret.

When I taught in Germany, in the mid 1980’s, the wall was still up between the East and the West. We were required to visit The Wall and found it to be multi-layered. The fence was laced with hidden mines, the road behind it was patrolled by soldiers in jeeps, the towers over all had searchlights and armed men. “It’s to protect you from the West Germans getting in,” the people on the East side were told.

Only, no one was ever caught trying to enter the East side of Germany. They were only shot trying to get out.

That experience, and the way I now feel America could become a country under leadership which is meant to protect us but only takes our freedom, echoed throughout my mind as I read this most fascinating novel.

19 thoughts on “Russian Winter by Daphne Kalotay”

  1. I was intrigued by this book when I first heard about it, but like your friend, Russian names intimidate me.Your review has eradicated that concern, however, and I look forward to reading it myself one day.


  2. I don't really get on with Russian literature but I am fascinated by its history. I did a module on the Russian revolution for my history GCSE and haven't look back since. I'll read practially anything non-fiction about Russia or communism.It must have been such an experience to be in Germany at that time. I was 3 when the wall came down and I can still remember my mum and dad jumping up and down in front of the television.


  3. Molly, there's no need to be intimidated in the slightest. The names of the characters are very easy, and it's really a wonderful story.BermudaOnion, that's what happened to me: I saw it on several blogs, and then when a friend of mine said he'd read it, I knew I had to pick it up. Fortunately, the library had a copy so I didn't have to buy one of my own.Elizabeth, this is far easier (and shorter) than War and Peace! Now that's a book with som extensive 'crazy names'! 😉 Still, it's a truly wonderful novel as I'm sure you're discovering.Melody, first let me give a long woverdue thank you for the novel (Star of the Sea) you sent me. It looks fabulous, and I really appreciate you taking the time and effort to ship it. Secondly, isn't Russia or communism fascinating? The thing about the later is I always think it should work in theory, and yet I see it so doesn't. How can individual effort and determination not be rewarded? Have you read Atlas Shrugged by Ayn Rand? That was a hugely pivotal book for me.Sam, it was amazing to be in Germany then. Lots was going on as Khadafi was pulling his antics too, blowing up parts of the airport in Frankfurt, or bars where American soldiers who were protecting the Western side of Germany hung out.


  4. I love the cover of that book and your enthusiasm for it – makes me realize how much I need to read more Russian Literature. I'll definitely be adding this one to my TBR list – it just sounds so fascinating. Thanks!


  5. Oh, Diane, you need to delve into some. This would be a good starting place, for mood at any rate.Nadia, there's another cover which shows a very wintry scene; it's gorgeous too, but this one is more familiar as it's the edition which is out and about now. Also, the amber pendant the auburn haired woman is wearing is very significant to the story. (And, her secret.)


  6. Sounds like an intriguing read. I used to love Russian Lit. in school, way back when Solzhenitsyn was popular. I've put them aside for decades but now you've made me curious again. Currently, I'm starting to read Sarah's Key, although not a Russian setting, it's also about a harsh regime… the Nazi's. Have you read it?


  7. Arti, I have a sample of Sarah's Key on my Nook, but I haven't read it yet. For some reason (the child on the cover?) it reminds me of Sophie's Choice, which was a very hard book for me emotionally. I never seem to cope very well with the destruction the Nazis caused in people's lives.


  8. Definitely one that I've had my eye on for a while. I took ballet as a child and felt certain that Mikhail Baryshnikov and I were meant to be. Anwho, that obviously didn't happen, so I now love to read anything related to Russia and ballet – so with this combining both interests, I'm even more motivated to get it and read it.Fascinating insight into your time in Germany – my father traveled quite a bit for business and he was able to visit the Wall once.


  9. I've never heard of this book or author before, but it sounds lovely, perfect seasonal reading. The cover is gorgeous and so tempting. It's incredible that you were able to be in Germany at that time…


  10. Living in Germany was one of the great highlights of my life. Not because of Germany, but because its central location gave us such a wonderful starting point to visit the other countries in Europe I love so much. That would be Italy and France. 😉


  11. It sounds like you felt a powerful connection to this book. My favorite books are always those that have me thinking on many different levels. It sounds like this one did that for you.


  12. Wonderful review, Bellezza! You worked in Germany when the wall was still there? Wow! I liked your last passage very much – "That experience, and the way I now feel America could become a country under leadership which is meant to protect us but only takes our freedom, echoed throughout my mind as I read this most fascinating novel" 🙂


  13. Vishy, you're the only one to pick up on my ending thought, which strikes me very powerfully. I used to believe America was the land of the free and the home of the brave, but now I very much fear this may not always be true. Our leadership, as well as outside forces, both make me very uncomfortable.


Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Google photo

You are commenting using your Google account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s